PSG dominated Rennes (5-0), but the interpretation of performances varies significantly between Le Parisien, L’Équipe, and your own ratings on VIPSG.fr. While all agree on the collective mastery, the discrepancies mainly arise from the evaluation of individual player impact, particularly in the offensive sector.
In attack, Kvaratskhelia receives an 8 in the press, while VIPSG.fr awards him a 9 for an exceptional double. A similar trend is seen for Barcola: rated 7 in the newspapers, he rises to 8.5 in your evaluations due to his constant dynamism. Mayulu is also rated slightly higher by you, with a 7.5 compared to 6.5 to 7 elsewhere. The case of Lee illustrates a difference in appreciation: Le Parisien gives him a 4, L’Équipe a 5, while VIPSG.fr retains a 5.5, highlighting interesting activity despite a major miss.
In midfield, the three sources generally converge on Vitinha and Joao Neves, although VIPSG.fr values the latter more, rating him 7 due to his assist and influence between the lines. Zaïre-Emery is unanimously rated well with a 7, but your ratings go up to 8, considering that his volume of play and importance in the team’s balance deserved an extra notch.
The substitutes also made an impact
At the back, Safonov receives a 7 in the national press but rises to 8 in your ratings thanks to his two decisive saves before the opening goal. Pacho, Marquinhos, and Lucas Hernandez receive similar ratings, although VIPSG.fr is slightly more generous, taking their overall solidity into account.
Finally, while Le Parisien and L’Équipe stop at the starting lineup, VIPSG.fr also analyzes the contributions of the substitutes. Mbaye, Ramos, and Dembélé receive positive ratings, notably Mbaye with a 7.5 after his stunning goal and Ramos with a 7 for his late goal, emphasizing that the Paris bench significantly contributed to the final display.
Overall, the press sees a serious, focused, and efficient PSG, while your ratings highlight individual brilliance and the ability of substitutes to increase the scoreline.
Ratings for PSG / Rennes
Le Parisien
Kvaratskhelia (8) – Mayulu (6.5) – Barcola (7)
Lee (4) – Vitinha (5) – Neves (6)
Hernandez (6) – Pacho (6.5) – Marquinhos (6) – Zaïre-Emery (7)
Safonov (7)
L’Équipe
Luis Enrique (7)
Kvaratskhelia (8) – Mayulu (7) – Barcola (7)
Lee (5) – Vitinha (5) – Neves (6)
Hernandez (6) – Pacho (6) – Marquinhos (6) – Zaïre-Emery (7)
Safonov (7)
VIPSG.fr
Safonov (8)
Pacho (7)
Marquinhos (7)
Lucas Hernandez (6)
Vitinha (6)
Joao Neves (7)
Zaïre-Emery (8)
Kvaratskhelia (9)
Barcola (8.5)
Lee (5.5)
Mayulu (7.5)
Dembélé (6)
Mbaye (7.5)
Gonçalo Ramos (7)
Related Posts:
